Can You Heal a Rotator Cuff Tear Without Surgery? What The Science Reveals About Shoulder Pain

When people hear they have a rotator cuff tear (RTC), it's common to feel fear or assume the worst: Will I lose function? Will I always be in pain? Do I need surgery?

But here’s the empowering truth: many people fully recover from RTC injuries without surgery. Even if tears don’t physically heal, pain can go away—and function can be restored. Let’s explore why that’s the case.

Rotator Cuff Pain Does Not Always Equal Damage

One of the most important distinctions to make is this: pain and function are not the same. Just because someone is in pain doesn’t mean their shoulder isn’t working. And just because imaging shows a tear doesn’t mean surgery is required.

Research shows that a significant proportion of full-thickness rotator cuff (RTC) tears are completely asymptomatic; people have these tears and feel no pain at all. Shoulder pain often correlates more closely with things like sleep disturbance, emotional stress, and mental health than it does with the size or location of a tear.

• A study published in the Journal of Orthopedics reported that among individuals over 60, asymptomatic rotator cuff tears were twice as common as symptomatic ones. Specifically, in their 50s, 50% of tears were asymptomatic; in those over 60, the prevalence of asymptomatic tears was significantly greater than that of symptomatic tears.

• Another study published in the National Library of Medicine found that the prevalence of asymptomatic partial-thickness and full-thickness rotator cuff tears ranged from 8% to 40% and from 0% to 46%, respectively.

These findings underscore the importance of correlating imaging results with clinical symptoms, as a tear on imaging does not necessarily indicate a symptomatic condition requiring surgical intervention. It also means that helping someone reduce fear, regulate their nervous system, and shift their beliefs about pain can lead to real and lasting relief—even in a tear.

Function First: When Rotator Cuff Surgery Might Be Necessary

Let's explore situations where structure matters—and where surgery may be appropriate. Let’s say a person falls and sustains a trauma to the shoulder. If imaging shows a significant tear of the infraspinatus or supraspinatus, and the individual physically cannot perform specific movements (like lifting their arm or keeping it externally rotated), that loss of function is a red flag.

But in many other cases, even when a tear is present, people still retain good mobility and strength; they have pain. And that’s a whole different story.

Conservative Care Should Always Come First

When someone has shoulder pain but can pass physical testing with only minor limitations, conservative care (like physical therapy, mind-body work, and nervous system regulation) is not only effective—it’s often the preferred route. Here’s why:

• The body has an incredible capacity for adaptation.

• The shoulder is supported by multiple muscles, allowing for compensation and healing even when one tendon is compromised.

• Structural changes to the shoulder, like partial tears or retraction, do not automatically impair function.

One myth that needs busting is that just because a tear is present doesn’t mean it’s new or related to the pain. That tear was likely there before the pain began and was an incidental finding in many cases.

Aging, Imaging, and Incidental Findings

As we age, changes in our musculoskeletal system are normal findings—just like wrinkles on the outside, we develop wear and tear on the inside. MRIs of asymptomatic people often show “damage” like:

• RTC tears

• Labral fraying

• Degeneration

That’s why imaging should never be the only thing driving the decision to operate.

What Really Matters: The Whole Picture

Before considering surgery, it’s critical to ask:

• When did the pain start, and what was happening in life at the time?

• Is there a history of trauma, or did the pain come on gradually?

• What are the person’s beliefs about their shoulder and what they have been told by others?

• Are they able to move their arm despite the pain?

These questions often reveal that the pain is not purely structural but linked to stress, fear, beliefs, and nervous system sensitivity.

If you're dealing with shoulder pain and have been told you have a tear, don’t panic. Surgery is not the only answer—and often not the best first step. Conservative care, including mind-body approaches, physical therapy, and strength training, can lead to incredible outcomes.

Remember, you can be structurally imperfect but still be fully functional and pain-free.

Your body is resilient. Your pain is real—but it doesn’t have to be permanent.

If you’re interested in exploring the root causes of your shoulder pain and want a holistic, empowering approach to healing, reach out. There’s always more we can do—together.

Full Pain Evaluation

Book Now